I am trying to calculate a asymptotic series expansion of a list.

Series[{0,-((R^2 ν (2+(-1+ν (2+ν)) Cos[2 θ]))/((-1+ν) (1+ν^2) r^2)) +

(R^4 ν (-7+5 ν (2+ν)+16 Cos[2 θ]+(-1+3 ν (2+ν)) Cos[4 θ]))/(4 (-1+ν) (1+ν^2) r^4) +

O[1/r]^6,-((R^2 ν (3+ν) Cos[θ] Sin[θ])/((1+ν^2) r^3))+O[1/r]^4,0}, {r,Infinity,3}]

I don’t understand why the 1/r^4 term shows up in the output. Even more, I can copy & paste this input

Series[-((R^2 ν (2+(-1+ν (2+ν)) Cos[2 θ]))/((-1+ν) (1+ν^2) r^2)) +

(R^4 ν (-7+5 ν (2+ν)+16 Cos[2 θ]+(-1+3 ν (2+ν)) Cos[4 θ]))/(4 (-1+ν) (1+ν^2) r^4) +

O[1/r]^6,{r,Infinity,3}]

but evaluating the following line gives an error message about the argument

Series[a/r^2+b/r^4+O[1/r]^6,{r,Infinity,3}]

Any input is highly appreciated.

=================

=================

1 Answer

1

=================

You have to remove the O[_]^_ from your input:

Series[{0, -((R^2 ν (2 + (-1 + ν (2 + ν)) Cos[2 θ]))/((-1 + ν) (1 + ν^2) r^2)) + (R^4 ν (-7 + 5 ν (2 + ν) + 16 Cos[2 θ] + (-1 + 3 ν (2 + ν)) Cos[4 θ]))/(4 (-1 + ν) (1 + ν^2) r^4), -((R^2 ν (3 + ν) Cos[θ] Sin[θ])/((1 + ν^2) r^3)), 0}, {r, Infinity, 3}]

Yes, but why? I mean why can’t Mathematica interpret it properly?

– user37022

Mar 23 ’13 at 2:01

4

Because O[1/r]^6 is just a display form for a more complicated thing. For example, if you compute Series[x, {x, \[Infinity], 5}], the frontend displays a nice x + O[1/x]^6, but that’s not the internal representation, which is SeriesData[x, DirectedInfinity[1], {1}, -1, 6, 1], as you can discover with FullForm. For this reason, you can either accurately copy and paste SeriesDatas without corrupting them or (better) leave out the O[_] placeholder (possibly with Normal).

– Federico

Mar 23 ’13 at 2:09