# Make integration/ plot run faster? (takes hours)

I am using Mathematica 10.0.2.0.

Here is the code I am working with:

w[u_] = (-u*x^2*f[t, x] + 0.5*D[f[t, x], x, x]);

wsol[u_] :=
NDSolve[{D[f[t, x], t] == w[u], f[0, x] == 1,
f[t, -50] == Exp[-1000 t], f[t, 50] == Exp[-1000 t]},
f, {t, 0, 100}, {x, -50, 50}, MaxStepSize -> 0.5,
AccuracyGoal -> 8, PrecisionGoal -> 8,
Method -> {“MethodOfLines”,
“SpatialDiscretization” -> {“TensorProductGrid”,
“MinPoints” -> 1000}}];

wl[t] = Evaluate[
Integrate[0.25*(x^2)*(f[t, x] /. wsol[0.25]), {x, -50, 50}]]

Plot[Evaluate[wl[t]], {t, 0.01, 100}, PlotRange -> All]

Perhaps, I am doing something wrong but it takes a long time to plot, or sometimes does not plot at all.

Instead of plotting, I tried putting the data in a list but that took too long as well.

Additionally, I would like to fit a function to the data as well and measure the area under the curve.

I would really appreciate some help. Thanks.

=================

do not integrate, do this process in NDSolve please. Try to make everything one more ‘ then the result will be the integration.
– Wjx
Jul 26 at 23:57

@Wjx I am not sure how to insert the 0.25∗x20.25∗x20.25*x^2 inside NDSolve.
– Edv Beq
Jul 27 at 0:09

I also found a big mistake w[t] should be w[t_];
– Edv Beq
Jul 27 at 0:24

Oh, then you can create another function and do the integration by D[newf[t,x],x]==0.25 x^2 f[t,x]
– Wjx
Jul 27 at 0:34

1

other issues aside, this code is repeatedly evaluating wsol with the same argument. Using memoization will help dramatically reference.wolfram.com/language/tutorial/…
– george2079
Jul 29 at 15:05

=================

1

=================

A quick solution with “SymbolicProcessing -> 0”:

w[u_] = (-u*x^2*f[t, x] + 0.5*D[f[t, x], x, x]);

wsol[u_] :=
NDSolve[{D[f[t, x], t] == w[u], f[0, x] == 1, f[t, -50] == Exp[-1000 t],
f[t, 50] == Exp[-1000 t]}, f, {t, 0, 100}, {x, -50, 50}];

core = f /. wsol[0.25][[1]]

wl[t_?NumericQ] :=
NIntegrate[0.25*(x^2)*core[t, x], {x, -50, 50},
Method -> {Automatic, “SymbolicProcessing” -> 0}, MaxRecursion -> 40]

Plot[wl[t], {t, 0.01, 100}] // AbsoluteTiming

How to speed up the plot of NIntegrate?

2

+1 — There seems to be quite a difference in wl[t] between the default 25-point x-grid and the 1001-point one of the OP or even a 101-point one. — For merely plotting, one can usually speed things up a little more by lowering the precision goal in NIntegrate to PrecisionGoal -> 4 (but beware as it is lowered, the chance that the error estimator gets tricked seems to increase).
– Michael E2
Jul 29 at 14:01

Thank you, it is significantly faster even with high precision. Magic!
– Edv Beq
Jul 30 at 0:09